Using Time-out for Child Conduct Problems in the Context of Trauma and Adversity: A Nonrandomized Controlled Trial
Roach, A. C., Lechowicz, M., Yiu, Y., Diaz, A. M., Hawes, D., & Dadds, M. R. (2022). Using time-out for child conduct problems in the context of trauma and adversity: a nonrandomized controlled trial. JAMA, 5(9), e2229726-e2229726.
Abstract
Importance: Exposure to adverse childhood experiences substantially increases the risk of chronic health problems. Originally designed to treat child conduct problems, parent management training programs have been shown to be effective in preventing children from being exposed to further adversity and supporting children’s recovery from adversity; however, there are increasing concerns that a core component of these programs, the discipline strategy time-out, may be harmful for children with a history of exposure to adversity.
Objective: To investigate the comparative benefits and potential harms to children exposed to adversity that are associated with parenting programs that include time-out.
Design, Setting, and Participants: This nonrandomized waiting list–controlled clinical study was conducted at a specialist clinic for the treatment of conduct problems in Sydney, Australia. The self-referred sample included children with conduct problems and their caregivers. Eligibility was confirmed through clinician-administered interviews. Data were collected between February 14, 2018, and February 1, 2021.
Interventions: Caregivers participated in a 10-session, social learning–based parent management training program. Caregivers were provided with parenting strategies aimed at encouraging desired behaviors through effective reinforcement and managing misbehavior through consistent limit setting, including the use of time-outs.
Main Outcomes and Measures: The primary outcome was the parent-reported Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire score, and secondary outcomes included subscale scores from the clinician-administered Diagnostic Interview Schedule for Children, Adolescents, and Parents. Multi-informant measures of child adversity were collected using the parent-reported Adverse Life Experiences Scale and the clinician-rated Maltreatment Index.
Results: A total of 205 children were included in analysis (156 in the full intervention and 49 in the control condition; 158 boys [77.1%]; mean [SD] age, 5.6 [1.8] years [range, 2-9 years]). Compared with children with low adversity exposure, children with high adversity exposure showed greater reductions in the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire score from baseline (mean difference, 3.46 [95% CI, 1.51-5.41]; P < .001) to after treatment (mean difference, 1.49 [95% CI, −0.46 to 3.44]; P = .13) and in the internalizing symptom subscale score (baseline mean difference, 1.00 [95% CI, −2,00 to 0.00]; P = .50; posttreatment mean difference, 0.06 [95% CI, −0.82 to 0.94]; P = .90). No significant differences in the externalizing symptom subscale score were found.
Conclusions and Relevance: In this nonrandomized clinical study, children with high exposure to adversity experienced equivalent, if not greater, benefits associated with parenting programs that include time-out compared with children with low exposure to adversity. Results suggest that time-out was an effective component of parenting programs for children exposed to adversity.
Recent Post
The Value of Early SEL Strategies in Childhood Development
How Teacher Training Programs Help School Districts Boost Student Outcomes
Effective Behavior Interventions to Establish Expectations at School
Transforming Education: Scalable Educational Interventions
Effective Inclusive Classroom Strategies for Teaching Students with Autism
Posts by Tag
- Research Library (310)
- Program (294)
- Key (292)
- Audience (288)
- Parent Training (251)
- All (250)
- Agencies and Administrators (192)
- Treatment (183)
- Prevention (144)
- Implementation and Dissemination (104)
- Therapists and Group Leaders (103)
- Implementation and Dissemination (84)
- All (73)
- Parents (62)
- Independent Replication (60)
- Teacher Training (55)
- Child Training (44)
- Assessment (41)
- Independent Replication (40)
- Teachers (38)
- Agencies and Administrators (37)
- Skill Development (37)
- Assessment (35)
- Therapists and Group Leaders (34)
- treatment (34)
- RCT (31)
- Teacher Training (28)
- Review (26)
- evidence-based (26)
- review (23)
- Prevention (21)
- At risk (20)
- Books (15)
- Parenting Program (15)
- child training (15)
- Randomized control trial (13)
- Parenting (12)
- Autism (11)
- Implementation (11)
- Programs (11)
- behavior problems (11)
- Incredible Years (9)
- Preschoolers (9)
- conduct problems (9)
- Social Emotional Learning (8)
- intervention (8)
- ADHD (7)
- Classroom (7)
- News (7)
- randomized control group trial (7)
- Early Intervention (6)
- Self-regulation (6)
- child development (6)
- parent training program (6)
- Key (5)
- Parenting Intervention (5)
- Program (5)
- Universal (5)
- conduct disorder (5)
- meta-analysis (5)
- Baby Program (4)
- Child behavior (4)
- Classroom Dinosaur (4)
- Fidelity (4)
- School (4)
- emotion regulation (4)
- Behavioral Health (3)
- Filipino (3)
- High-risk (3)
- News (3)
- Social competence (3)
- child protective services (3)
- cost effectiveness (3)
- cultural adaptation (3)
- dissemination (3)
- effectiveness (3)
- parent involvement (3)
- parent-teacher relations (3)
- positive behavior management (3)
- teacher perception (3)
- trauma (3)
- Aggressive Behavior (2)
- Basic Parent Program (2)
- CPS (2)
- Children (2)
- Developmental Disability (2)
- Disruptive behavior (2)
- Early childhood (2)
- Feasibility (2)
- Home Coaching (2)
- Hyperactivity (2)
- Infant (2)
- International (2)
- Mental Health (2)
- Parent Home Coaching (2)
- Research (2)
- STARS (2)
- STEER (2)
- School readiness (2)
- TCM (2)
- behavioral difficulties (2)
- behavioral problems (2)
- child behavior problems (2)
- child maltreatment (2)
- classroom intervention (2)
- collaborative (2)
- consultation (2)
- culturally tailored (2)
- economically disadvantaged (2)
- emotional difficulties (2)
- foster care (2)
- goals (2)
- group based (2)
- mediation (2)
- objectives (2)
- residential care (2)
- review of literature (2)
- school aged (2)
- social and emotional competence (2)
- social development (2)
- student-teacher relationship (2)
- sustainability (2)
- teacher change (2)
- teacher wellbeing (2)
- theoretical foundation (2)
- Attentive Parenting (1)
- Behavior Management (1)
- Caregivers (1)
- Child Welfare (1)
- Child-Directed Play (1)
- Child–teacher relationship (1)
- Classroom climate (1)
- Coping (1)
- Denmark (1)
- Evidence-Based Practices (1)
- Families (1)
- Family (1)
- Flying Start (1)
- Foucault (1)
- Gipuzkoa (1)
- Hmong (1)
- Home learning environment (1)
- IY TCM (1)
- Implantación (1)
- Innovation (1)
- Kindergarten (1)
- Māori (1)
- News (1)
- ODD (1)
- Parent stress (1)
- Parenting interventions (1)
- Preschool Children (1)
- Programas basados en la evidencia (1)
- Protección infantil (1)
- Public Health (1)
- Rural schools (1)
- Scaling up (1)
- Small Group Treatment (1)
- Social-emotional well being (1)
- Spain (1)
- Sure Start (1)
- Time Out (1)
- Toddler parenting Program (1)
- Trauma-informed (1)
- Wales (1)
- abuse (1)
- academic achievement (1)
- academic competence (1)
- academic problems (1)
- activity (1)
- age effects (1)
- attachment (1)
- attendance (1)
- behavior regulation (1)
- behavioral intervention (1)
- behavioral interventions (1)
- central nervous system (1)
- child behavior program (1)
- child care (1)
- child experience (1)
- child program (1)
- child training program (1)
- childcare (1)
- childhood (1)
- childhood conduct problems (1)
- classroom conduct (1)
- clinically significant improvement (1)
- collaborating (1)
- collaborative processes (1)
- content (1)
- cost-effective (1)
- costing (1)
- cultural adaptations (1)
- cultural responsiveness (1)
- early education (1)
- economic disadvantage (1)
- education (1)
- elementary (1)
- elementary school (1)
- emotional development (1)
- emotional health (1)
- emotional problems (1)
- engagement (1)
- evaluation (1)
- evidence-based parenting group (1)
- externalizing (1)
- externalizing behavior (1)
- fidélité (1)
- health (1)
- health disparities (1)
- healthy life style (1)
- home parent support (1)
- home visiting (1)
- home-based (1)
- implantation (1)
- independent research (1)
- independent review (1)
- internalizing (1)
- interpersonal competence (1)
- language delays (1)
- language development (1)
- latent transition analysis (1)
- malnutrition (1)
- maltreatment (1)
- maternal depression (1)
- mental health care (1)
- methods (1)
- neglect (1)
- nutrition (1)
- obesity (1)
- oppositional defiant disorder (1)
- parent perception (1)
- parent practices (1)
- participation (1)
- peer problems (1)
- pilot (1)
- post-colonisation (1)
- post-structuralism (1)
- primary care (1)
- primary school (1)
- problem solving (1)
- processes (1)
- professional development (1)
- program evaluation (1)
- prosocial behavior (1)
- qualitative analysis (1)
- rationale (1)
- residential child care (1)
- satisfaction (1)
- scaling (1)
- self-efficacy (1)
- single parents (1)
- social behavior (1)
- social communication (1)
- social problem solving (1)
- socioemotional and behavioural difficulties (1)
- special educational needs (1)
- staff training (1)
- stress (1)
- student outcomes (1)
- teacher behavior (1)
- teacher behaviour (1)
- teacher self-efficacy (1)
- teacher stress (1)
- therapist (1)
- therapists (1)
- therapy (1)
- transportability (1)
- video-based modeling (1)
- well-being (1)